Blog / Iowa Caucus: It’s a Marathon AND a Sprint! Topics  

Iowa Caucus: It’s a Marathon AND a Sprint!

Voters have finally had their first say in the 2016 presidential race. Iowa caucus-goers gathered at locations across the state to listen to speeches and to officially throw their support behind a certain candidate.

Now it’s time to dissect official results against what we predicted.

Once again, our hypothesis is that social media analytics are better at predicting election outcomes than traditional polling.

Iowa was our first test to this theory.

So, now we come to the most important question of the night:

How did we do?

Let’s start with – 

The Republicans

Was Ted’s win a surprise?

At 4:42 PM yesterday, we updated our forecast by including data from 12 AM Sunday, Jan 31st up to 4 PM Monday, Feb 1st. We saw Ted taking a slight lead over Donald then, but Donald was slightly ahead when we expanded the data set to include Friday and Saturday. We knew it was going to be a VERY tight race.

Image 1 - Original

At 6 PM, as broadcasted by CNN, Ted knew it was a tight race and rallied his team to get supporters out to caucus. It has been documented that Ted’s Iowa team is well organized. Props to Ted. He used real-time insights from his ground troops, and turned to action to secure the win.

Image 2

As a side note, many news outlets reported on Ben Carson’s claim of campaign sabotage by Ted’s supporters.  We immediately picked up these tweets with our monitoring capabilities.

Rubio’s Rise

My wife and in-laws are politically passionate. Two of them are GOP supporters, two are DEM. It makes for lively discussion whenever we get together. As a Permanent U.S. Resident, I can’t vote and never join their arguments debates. But at 5:50 PM, I emailed them updated data, including details that Rubio was doing well yesterday (data I pulled on Monday up until 4 PM). They were very happy about this.

Image 3

What about Ben & Ted?

Our data showed Ben at 1% versus 9% in the caucus. This is somewhat puzzling to me because Ben was consistently in the top spots (2 through 4) in our national weekly benchmark reports — we started these in August. His numbers started dropping in late November and have never recovered. Likewise, we had Jeb in fourth at 6%, versus sixth place and 2.8%. We need to dig into this further, but in Jeb’s case, I theorize it’s tied to the huge amount of money he spent in Iowa, as reported by The Weekly Standard, and didn’t turn into actual votes. 

The Democrats

RealClearPolitics shows that Hillary has consistently polled as the front runner. Using data from Friday to Saturday, we had her leading by 3, in-line with the respected Des Moines Register / Bloomberg Poll. But we saw Bernie surging on Sunday and Monday.  

Combined Image

I wanted to understand why our data suggested Bernie would win. I believe there are three logical reasons:

1. Demographics: Age

Social media attracts a younger audience, most notably Millennials. With the youngest being 19 and able to vote now, Millennials are set to overtake Boomers in population this year. But that doesn’t translate to more votes. As reported by a recent Tufts research report, Millennials are less likely to vote than older generations. To win, Bernie will have to get more of them to participate. I pulled in data using the same filters as yesterday and found that Bernie’s audience over-indexes to Millennial when compared to Hillary:  

Image 4

We believe the generational composition differences between the two candidates’ social media supporters contribute to the reason why our prediction differs from final results. We plan to reevaluate this and to determine if we need to adjust our algorithm to replicate real-world generational voting patterns.

2. Gender

Social media conversations about Hillary skew more female.    

Image 5

3. Democratic Procedure

As explained by NPR, Democrats require candidates to secure a 15% viability threshold in each caucus. If they don’t, those supporters have to re-caucus and choose another candidate. As Martin O’Malley never got out of single digit support, we think many of his supporters could have voted for Hillary.  

Our Predictions Were More Accurate

With a good methodology and tool set, benchmarking recent history and analyzing real-time data provides extensive view into trends you are unable to get from polling. While nothing can be 100% accurate, these social media insights will arm candidates, journalists and pundits with an ability to see and react to changes as they happen. We will be ready for New Hampshire next week, and will be looking forward to refining our approach throughout the 2016 Presidential Elections.

Game on, Pollsters! Keep up on our election coverage by following us on Twitter @Zoomph_Politics

Topics:
WP_Term Object ( [term_id] => 729 [name] => Social Media Analytics Resources [slug] => social-media-analytics-resources [term_group] => 0 [term_taxonomy_id] => 730 [taxonomy] => capabilities [description] => Our latest blogs showcasing how social analytics uncover insights about audiences and content that resonate with your brand. [parent] => 0 [count] => 62 [filter] => raw [object_id] => 9904 )
Analytics & Insights
WP_Term Object ( [term_id] => 728 [name] => Social Media Monitoring Resources [slug] => social-media-monitoring-resources [term_group] => 0 [term_taxonomy_id] => 729 [taxonomy] => capabilities [description] => A collection of advice on how social monitoring can help you spot trends and keep tabs on your competition. [parent] => 0 [count] => 40 [filter] => raw [object_id] => 9904 )
Monitoring & Tracking
WP_Term Object ( [term_id] => 733 [name] => Social Media News and Trends [slug] => social-media-news-trends [term_group] => 0 [term_taxonomy_id] => 734 [taxonomy] => updates [description] => Get the scoop on social news and trends, plus expert analyses, advice, and hacks for joining the most important conversations. [parent] => 0 [count] => 128 [filter] => raw [object_id] => 9904 )
News & Trends

Subscribe to Zoomph's Newsletter

Hashtag for Jerusalem: Turning the Global Spotlight on the Holy City [Case Study]

January 11, 2017

During the 2016 holiday season, Jerusalem–a city holy to many of faith—embarked on a campaign to engage its global community and invite them to use social media as a means to spread the holiday spirit.… Read More

Top Milestones for Zoomph-Sponsored “Why I Social” Podcast

January 10, 2017

Having settled into 2017, it’s a great time to look back and reflect on what made 2016 a very successful second year for the "Why I Social" podcast. The last six months have been particularly exciting,… Read More

Employee Spotlight: James Ho

January 05, 2017

James' unequaled love of golf and die-hard loyalty to Nike is analogous to the punch and passion he brings to our team. While a leader in his own right, James is a team player. He… Read More

Application Logging for Developers: 3 Common Pitfalls

January 04, 2017

The Un-Ignorable Importance of Logging Regardless of what you call it—event logging, application logging, or just plain logging—logging is one of the most important sources of information for the healthy operation of any IT system.… Read More

All Posts